View Full Version: Help! I am Catholic and Protestant

Ancient and Future Catholic Forum and Discussion > Everything Catholic: Theology, Questions, Morality, Issues, etc > Help! I am Catholic and Protestant



Title: Help! I am Catholic and Protestant
Description: Catholics and Traditional Protestants


kenfollis@juno.com - September 21, 2006 05:25 PM (GMT)
QUOTE
I was happy to try to become an "evangelical catholic" Lutheran priest in the ELCA.  Well, unfortunately for me, the "evangelical catholic" movement is evaporating quickly, though I am in an oratory for Lutheran pastors who pledge to pray the daily offices, restore the use of private confession, and work for closer relations with the bishop and church of Rome.  Phillip Johnson, just became a Catholic on Sunday, and other "evangelical catholic" Lutherans like Richard John Neuhaus, Jaroslav Pelikan (God bless his soul), Reinhard Hutter, Jay Rochelle, and others have left for Rome or Constantinople.  I have mixed feelings about it all. Meanwhile, I am a married pastor with children. I am not eligible for the "Pastoral Provision" that allows Lutheran and Episcopal priests to become Catholic priests and keep their wives, because I was confirmed by a Catholic bishop and am therefore ruled out.  But I really would return to the RCC as a "gatekeeper", or find some way of moving toward that direction, if I *really* thought it was correct in all its teachings.  As you can tell, I have lots of difficulties with various teachings, however, so I am honestly not convinced that it is The True Church.  But I am open to being convinced. Were you connected with the CEC at some point, or is this just your apostolate to defend the Catholic Faith? Thank you for this opportunity to share a bit about myself.  I hope it wasn't too boring!  Blessings upon your work, Ken.  I admire your love for the Church and the Lord.

kenfollis@juno.com - September 21, 2006 05:31 PM (GMT)
QUOTE
I do trust deeply in the words of our Lord, "the gates of hades will never
hold out against it" and "I am with you always".  This must mean that there
will *always* be a Body of Christ on earth until He comes, always a
gathered, baptized assembly of believers who call upon the name of Jesus. This is sometimes called the "indefectibility" of the Church, and I
wholeheartedly accept that.

So, I trust basically that when it comes to our living *relationship* with
God the Father, Son and Spirit, Christ the Son keeps us from going off the
rails completely.  He does allow sin and error, but never to the point where
our relationship with Christ will be destroyed.

This may, or may not, mean that every doctrine is inerrantly formulated.

And, even if the RCC were proven to be incorrect on some doctrines, that
does *not* mean God has abandoned her.  Just as Elijah and Elisha and Amos,
etc., were active in the Northern Tribes that split from David's line, so I
believe God is active and working in *any* baptized and gathered assembly
that calls on Jesus's name, whether they are all right, or only partially
correct, in every jot and tittle of teaching.  CHRIST is the Truth; our
formulations may be lacking, but He is not.

Whether the RCC is perfect in teaching or not, God or the angels or saints may still work powerfully in its midst for salvation, life and healing.


All comments are welcome for this brother!

A Simple Sinner - October 20, 2006 08:03 AM (GMT)
QUOTE (kenfollis@juno.com @ Sep 21 2006, 12:25 PM)
I am not eligible for the "Pastoral Provision" that allows Lutheran and Episcopal priests to become Catholic priests and keep their wives, because I was confirmed by a Catholic bishop and am therefore ruled out. 

If there is one thing the Catholic Church could REALLY use right now it is a good deacon offering solid orthodox homilies.

Additionally, your Catholic confirmation and your married state would be NO impediment to ordination in the Byzantine Catholic Church. They too could use the priests.

Melkite Vocations Director
Rt.Rev. Fr. Philip Raczka,
St. Joseph Church,
600 W. Exchange St.,
Akron, OH 44302
(330) 535-7364

Byzantine Catholic Archeparchy of Pittsburgh
His Eminence, Metropolitan Archbishop BASIL
Chancery Office
66 Riverview AV
Pittsburgh, PA 15214-2253
Phone: 412-231-4000
Fax: 412-231-1697

Certainly you are not the first one to have these issues. Perhaps contacting the very good people at the Coming Home Network would give you a good idea as to where a place in the church might be found for your talents.

http://www.chnetwork.org/

Simple





Hosted for free by InvisionFree